Been There, Done That and Left My Mark: Unfinished Business in Siem Reap Schools | William C. Brehm

PB020054Today Iveta, Ciara, and I visited six schools throughout Siem Reap province, 4 Caring for Cambodia and 2 government schools. Although the CFC schools and the government schools were hugely different (see Ciara’s blog tomorrow), one theme appeared in all the schools: the unfinished business of education development projects by all types of donors.

Why does the Korean government donate an electric piano to a school without enough electricity? Why would the Japanese NGO install large, concrete garbage containers without explaining how to use them to the schoolteachers and students? Why would the Prime Minister and his wife donate 50 sewing machines without thread or instructions?  Why would an international philanthropist donate a basketball court without including basketballs? Why would the Rotary Club of Japan install four water filtration systems displaying their name in bold letters but not providing instructions for maintenance?

PB010045In fact—come to think of it—all of these projects have large signs displaying the donors name or institution. It doesn’t matter if it was an NGO, development bank, government official, or individual donor—all of these projects neglected the essential aspects of the development initiatives: understanding the context of the school (having an enough electricity to power the piano), knowing the capacity of the school (teaching teachers and students how to throw garbage away), or thinking about sustainability of a project (training the community how to maintain water filters).

The theme is clear (in Khmer, “Same Same but different”). See tomorrow’s update for the next episode.

  • Carol
    It is great reading your updates. Please keep them coming! Ciara, while it is sad that basic skills are not being taught adequately, it is refreshing to know that children can express themselves and learn through art. Will, it is somewhat pathetic to know that the donors are "neglecting the essential aspects of the development initiatives" by not providing the corresponding resources (i.e. basketballs) or instructions (garbage disposal). Do you think the donors are more concerned with being noticed for their philanthropy (large display of donor name) or truly making a difference in the lives of the Cambodians? I hope it is the latter! Glad to know that you guys are making a difference. Enjoy the rest of the experience!!!
  • Mike
    If they have some of the hardware in place, but need the know how maybe that can be what Lehigh brings to the table. I'm sure we can figure out how to use the garbage system and maybe even teach the locals. (or "build capacity in the sanitary sector of the local mixed command/market economy while incorporating traditional waste management values" to use the buzzwords)
  • Katie Welsh Radande
    Will - great to hear from you guys! At least with the large donor signs it is obvious who to follow up with to give feedback about the projects......Hope all is going well and looking forward to hearing all about your experiences when you get back!
  • Wouter Hendrix
    Hey guys,
    Glad to hear you are doing well and everything is going according to plan. It is quite frustrating to hear that many donors only care about putting their name on the project without actually thinking about its sustainability. Brings us to the question whether a dysfunctional donation is better than no donation at all...

    Keep up the good work and safe travels

    Wouter
blog comments powered by Disqus